Confused between live-in and part-time maids in Singapore? Here’s a simple guide to help you choose the best fit for your home, lifestyle, and daily needs.
It’s a decision that affects your daily life, home routine, privacy, and even your finances so it’s not one to take lightly. Whether you’re a busy working couple juggling office hours and parenting, a multi-generational household needing elderly care, or someone who just wants help keeping the house tidy, the type of maid you choose can make a big difference.Singapore offers both live-in and part-time domestic helpers, each with its own pros and cons. But how do you decide what fits best for your lifestyle? Is round-the-clock support necessary, or would a few hours of help a week do the job?
This guide will walk you through the key differences between live-in and part-time maids in Singapore, highlight their unique benefits and challenges, and help you assess which option is the right fit for your home.
Understanding the Two Options
Before we compare, let’s clarify what each type actually means. In Singapore, domestic helpers generally fall into two categories: live-in maids and part-time maids. Both can make home life more manageable, but their roles, availability, and responsibilities are quite different.
Knowing what each option truly offers will help you avoid mismatched expectations and choose a setup that genuinely supports your household’s needs. Let’s take a quick look at what each one involves.
Live-In Maids in Singapore
Live-in maids are full-time domestic helpers who stay in your home. They’re available most of the day and handle a wide range of duties from cooking and cleaning to child or elder care.
Part-Time Maids in Singapore
Part-time maids work only a few hours per week or month. They don’t live in and usually help with general cleaning or light household chores.
The Case for Live-In Maids
If your household has heavy domestic needs, a live-in maid might be the right choice.
1. Around-the-Clock Support
One of the biggest advantages? They’re always around. Whether it’s early morning breakfast prep or emergency baby care at midnight, a live-in maid offers flexibility and peace of mind.
2. Ideal for Families with Kids or Elderly
Parents with young children or those caring for elderly parents find live-in maids especially helpful. They can assist with feeding, bathing, companionship, and medication reminders.
3. Broader Responsibilities
From laundry and ironing to running errands, a live-in maid usually takes on more responsibilities than a part-time helper.
4. Cost Over Time
While the monthly salary may seem high initially, the cost per hour is often lower than hiring part-time help multiple times a week.
The Flip Side of Live-In Maids
They’re not for everyone. Here’s why:
1. Privacy Concerns
Having someone live with you means less personal space. Some families find it hard to adjust to this, especially in smaller flats.
2. Higher Commitment
Live-in maids require a legal work permit, medical insurance, and sometimes agency fees. You’re also responsible for their well-being and accommodation.
3. Compatibility Issues
Since they live with you, it’s crucial that the maid gets along with your family. Miscommunication or clashes in habits can become stressful.
Why People Prefer Part-Time Maids
If you’re just looking for someone to help with cleaning once or twice a week, a part-time maid can be more suitable.
1. More Affordable
You only pay for the hours worked. No need for lodging, meals, or extra benefits.
2. Less Legal Work
Hiring a part-time maid through an agency often skips the whole MOM (Ministry of Manpower) process. There’s less paperwork and less commitment.
3. Flexibility
Want help just before guests arrive or after a party? Part-time maids give you the option to schedule as needed.
4. No Lifestyle Changes
Since they don’t live in, your privacy stays intact. You won’t have to adjust your routines to accommodate someone in your home 24/7.
Drawbacks of Part-Time Maids
They sound convenient, but they come with their own set of limitations.
1. Limited Hours
If something urgent comes up, your maid may not be available. You’ll need to wait till the next scheduled session.
2. Fewer Services
Part-time maids generally focus on basic tasks like mopping, dusting, or toilet cleaning. They may not offer childcare or cooking.
3. Higher Cost per Hour
Even though overall costs are lower, the hourly rate is typically higher than a live-in maid’s.
Comparing Both Options Side by Side
| Feature | Live-In Maids | Part-Time Maids |
| Availability | 24/7 | Limited (pre-booked hours) |
| Tasks | Full household help | Mainly cleaning tasks |
| Privacy | Reduced | Full privacy |
| Legal Requirements | Yes (Work Permit, Insurance, etc.) | Minimal (agency-based) |
| Cost (Monthly) | Higher overall but cheaper per hour | Lower overall but higher per hour |
| Ideal For | Families with kids, elderly, large homes | Small families, singles, low-maintenance homes |
So, Which One Should You Choose?
Here’s a quick cheat sheet to help you decide:
- Choose a live-in maid if:
- You need help daily or throughout the day.
- You have elderly family members or young kids.
- You don’t mind sharing your home space.
- Choose a part-time maid if:
- You live in a small space
- Your chores are light and manageable.
- You prefer flexibility and lower commitment.
Still unsure? Start with a part-time maid. You can always upgrade later once you understand your household’s needs better.
FAQs: Maids in Singapore
1. Can I switch from a part-time to a live-in maid later?
Yes. Many families start with part-time help and move to live-in maids as their needs grow.
2. Are part-time maids legal in Singapore?
Yes, but only Singaporeans or PRs can work as freelance part-time maids. Foreign part-timers must be from licensed agencies.
3. How much does a live-in maid typically cost?
Monthly salaries range from SGD 600–900, depending on nationality and experience. Plus, add levy, food, and insurance.
4. Is it cheaper to hire a part-time maid long-term?
Not always. If you need help more than 3 times a week, the cost may add up to what a live-in maid earns.
5. Do I have to provide food for live-in maids?
Yes. As an employer, you’re expected to provide meals or a food allowance.
6. What tasks can a part-time maid handle?
Mostly cleaning tasks: sweeping, mopping, dusting, toilet scrubbing, and kitchen cleanup.
7. Can live-in maids cook?
Absolutely. You can train them to cook meals for the family or follow recipes if they’re new.
8. Is hiring through an agency necessary?
It’s recommended. Licensed agencies ensure background checks, training, and replacements if needed.
9. How many hours can a part-time maid work per session?
Usually 3–4 hours per visit, depending on your contract.
10. What if my live-in maid wants to leave early?
You can terminate the contract, but there may be repatriation costs or notice periods as per the agreement.
Maids in Singapore play a huge role in supporting busy families, and choosing the right type is key to ensuring a comfortable home life. It’s not about which type is “better,” but rather which one fits your lifestyle, space, and needs.Whether you go for live-in or part-time, always hire through licensed agencies, clearly set expectations, and maintain good communication.A good maid isn’t just help they’re a long-term support system.